Lebanese security agencies have protested being asked to investigate the killing of former Iraqi MP Ahmed al-Alwani, described as a “modern, transient issue that will be forgotten tomorrow”, while they grapple with the chicken-and-egg causality paradox, one of the world’s oldest questions.
Chief Prosecutor Ahmad Rami al-Hajj is overseeing the al-Alwani investigation, conducted by the ISF Information Branch. But a security source said the agencies were in a "critical phase" of their decades-long inquiry into the paradox. Diverting resources to what they called “social media distraction”, involving a body, camera footage, and the questioning of living witnesses, would be "disruptive".
Investigators have narrowed the suspects in the classic case down to two: a chicken and an egg.
The investigation into former Prime Minister Rafic Hariri's assassination had taught investigators to distinguish between perpetrators, masterminds, accomplices, and witnesses. Under UN investigators Detlev Mehlis and Serge Brammertz, and later the Special Tribunal for Lebanon, these distinctions had been painstakingly refined. Establishing that the egg came from the chicken did not necessarily make the chicken the mastermind, as it might have been acting on orders from higher up the food chain, or the egg might have been an independent operation. Either way, the source noted, it was best not to jump to any conclusions.
The Beirut port explosion inquiry offered another valuable lesson. Judge Fadi Sawan was removed in 2021 after charging two former ministers, while his successor, Judge Tarek Bitar, faced repeated attempts to have him dismissed before filing his report in March 2026. Some 2,750 tonnes of ammonium nitrate had sat in a warehouse for years without anyone being held responsible. Against that precedent, the source suggested, there was little reason to rush to hold three men responsible for strangling a foreign national in an apartment rented for $200.
The source warned that the al-Aluwani case threatened to "derail years of progress". Identifying the perpetrator, masterminds, and accomplices from surveillance footage would divert resources still allocated to the classic chicken-and-egg causality paradox. Worse, it might require questioning suspects while they were still breathing, a logistical challenge for a security apparatus known to beat them to death. Compared with the grand question of which came first, the chicken or the egg, the source said, murder was transient, a footnote in the great questions of history.




